Alexander Revisited: The Final Cut
Normally, when an auteur undertakes a "Director's Cut," it's often the sign that he's been allowed to return to the film and add footage that the studio excised, either for length or content. In the case of Oliver Stone's Alexander (2004), Stone did that, but not for the actual "Director's Cut." There are now three versions of his Alexander: The 175-minute theatrical cut, the official "Director's Cut" version that's shorter at 167 minutes, and finally Alexander Revisited: The Final Cut which is the longest version at 214 minutes. Ultimately, all and none are the "director's cut"; Stone has tinkered enough to render the idea of a definitive version useless. But it also seems likely that his endless revising is a way to squeeze money out of a lemon, and is endemic of our times. The stateside box office failure of Alexander (it cost a reported $155 million and grossed only $34 domestically) likely caused those looking at a lot of red ink on the balance sheet to hope that DVD sales will push the film into something nearing profitable returns. Which, with the staggering though mostly unreported numbers that DVD sales generate, isn't as pie-eyed as it might appear, and the multiple versions may convince some to try the film again. Theatrically, Alexander was a meandering, near-interminable 175 minutes. Stone managed to fix some pacing issues with the Director's Cut, but he never found his narrative hook. With Alexander Revisited: The Final Cut, the structure of the opening half of the movie is tinkered with and new footage added, but Stone still doesn't find his film. Told in flashbacks by an aged Ptolemy (Anthony Hopkins), the picture follows the life of Alexander the Great (played as a teenager onwards by Colin Farrell) from childhood to his early demise at 33. Of major influence over his life are his father King Phillip (Val Kilmer) and his mother Olympias (Angelina Jolie). Both fight for possession of their son's soul, with his father offering discipline mostly for the boy's own good, while his mother is smothering and plots to help her child become king. Alexander proves himself at the Battle of Gaugamela, and thus begins his uninterrupted streak of military conquests for which he became legendary. But while he expands his empire, in marriage Alexander chooses a commoner named Roxanne (Rosario Dawson), and he also has a relationship with Hephiastion (Jared Leto) and in the final cut his bisexuality is played up with another of his male lovers.
* * *
One of the uniting themes of Oliver Stone's work is chaos he's fascinated by the bedlam that surrounds his protagonists, from Salvador to Nixon. And as Stone's career has progressed, he's extended this chaos to his audience, pioneering a technique he calls "lateral editing," wherein the dense visual imagery (in JFK and Natural Born Killers) creates a sense of heightened paranoia. Unfortunately, in Alexander this swirl of disorder mostly concerns the narrative Stone seems at a loss when it comes to telling the story, something that corrupts all three versions. The core of the drama ties into Alexander's relationship to his parents, and Stone's fascination with Oedipal issues is palpable. In this case it's implied that Olympias killed Phillip, while Roxanne's character bears more than a passing resemblance to Olympias, and Alexander's desire to keep conquering new worlds is tied to his distaste for, and attraction to, mommy. Colin Farrell is commanding as the renowned emperor and he leads well, but he gets lost in the middle of the story it's Val Kilmer who walks away with the picture. Stone still has a talent with the visuals, and there are moments (such as the horses vs. elephants battle toward the end) that are impressive. But even in the first major battle of Gaugamela, it's hard to tell who's winning or losing, and why. Alexander shares its greatest appeal with its historical-epic predecessors in that it's most enjoyable for the costumes, the scale, and the unintentional camp. Like Scorsese's Gangs of New York, Stone's film was a personal, long-desired project. And like Gangs, it may have been worked over too many times in the director's head to allow a coherent story to emerge. Unfortunately, the DVD format has offered Stone an opportunity to keep tinkering. Here's hoping this third iteration is the last. Warner's two-disc DVD release of Alexander Revisited: The Final Cut presents the film spread out over two discs in a good anamorphic transfer (2.35:1) and Dolby Digital 5.1 audio. Disc One offers a introduction by Oliver Stone (4 min.), which is the film's sole supplement. Dual-DVD slimline keep-case.